Showing posts with label reform. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reform. Show all posts

Sunday, June 14, 2015

Update: rally against insurers deemed “a great success”

by |




  • Brian on 2015-06-07 9:58:11 AM
    When will the dubious "preferred vendors" of the Ontario auto insurers' "proof" of massive opportunistic fraud be put under scrutiny? Systemic, bogus accusations of malingering churned out by pro-insurer medico-legal
    'experts' are first used (on a case by case basis) to deny benefits and then, in turn, trotted out by the Liberals as proof, on a policy level, that quad/paraplegics and brain inured accident victims are being treated "over-generously" and getting money "that needs to go to the people who really need it". We need to look at the long trail of sketchy "medical authorities" that Ontario governments have used to attack the credibility of the injured and the honesty of all Ontario motorists - a trail reaching all the way back to Dr. James N. Sears (aka Dimitri the Lover) - the insurer's "medical authority"
    behind the Harris "Rate Stability Act". And here we are: deja vue all over again!!!
  • Brian on 2015-06-07 10:28:09 AM
    In terms of cause - one can draw a straight line between these latest cuts to the catastrophically injured back to the Liberal/IBC cherry-picked Panel of Experts on Catastrophic Injury which concluded that what counts as "catastrophic" injury is too generous and that the criteria needs to be made tougher for the most seriously injured to "thread" the catastrophic injury definition "needle". The Liberals have decided to double-down on that insurer-friendly report and use at not just to come up with a more narrow definition of catastrophic injury - but also to justify cutting in half the treatment and attendant care benefits of the handful of injured claimants who will ever be able meet the upcoming stricter/tougher/revised catastrophic injury definition. All this thanks to a Panel of "preferred" insurer IME vendors and a couple of epidemiologists who never have and never will meet (much less treat) a catastrophically injured auto accident victim.
  • Rick on 2015-06-07 7:31:56 PM
    So coverage will be cut in half. I guess there's a refund on its way to everyone. Fat chance of that ever happening. Good on this group of concerned citizens for getting out there and making some noise about the evaporating coverage Ontario has. They've forgotten that they are selling, we are buying so we expect something for all those $billions we pay for coverage besides converting our policy dollars to Liberal campaign contributions.
  • Brian on 2015-06-07 11:38:10 PM
    Ironically, the editorial position in today's Sunday Sun has some choice words to say about the Ontario auto insurers' "shady practices":
    http://www.torontosun.com/2015/06/06/car-crash-victims-deserve-better-deal

    Prior to the passage of the budget, Finance Minister Charles Sousa boasted, “Ontario is the most generous in Canada when it comes to providing coverage for auto insurance.”

    Last week, Sun legal affairs analyst Alan Shanoff, demonstrated conclusively in his column how this statement was inaccurate.

    In fact, Ontario doesn’t provide the most generous benefits for either catastrophic injuries or for so-called “minor” ones, which can include dislocation of joints, partial tears of tendons and ligaments and whiplash not exhibiting neurological symptoms.

    As the FAIR Association of Victims for Accident Insurance Reform put it: “The budget does nothing to ensure that insurer claims management practices are fair and there has been no action (to deal with) ... the biased and corrupt insurer medical examination reports that are disqualifying innocent and legitimate accident victims.”

    We agree. It’s time to end this type of insurance fraud, as well.

  • Brian on 2015-06-08 1:34:55 PM
    The insurers say they won’t tolerate auto insurance fraud. Nor should they. So was this National Claims Manager (below) prosecuted – or not? If not – why the double standard? Is insider fraud tolerable?

    http://www.lawtimesnews.com/201012062960/inside-story/monday-december-6-2010
    Share


    LAWYER HELPED IN $1.5M FRAUD
    A Toronto lawyer has had his licence revoked for his part in a $1.5-million insurance fraud.

    Pradeep Bridglal Pachai admitted to taking part in a scheme that saw a senior employee at an insurance company client authorize higher payments to settle litigation than was needed and the two men pocketing the difference.

    Pachai claimed he was pressured into the scheme by Vinti Sansanwal, national claims director at HB Group Insurance Management Ltd., fearing he would cut him off from legal work defending the company, which had become his largest client.

    Initially, Pachai said he thought the arrangement was for one time only, but between 2005 and 2007, the scam snowballed, netting the pair $1.5 million from 11 files with the lawyer keeping $675,000 of the spoils for his role.

    The scheme came crashing down after an anonymous tip led to an investigation and Sansanwal’s dismissal. The insurance company then launched a civil action to recover the funds that named Pachai as a defendant. After he made restitution, the claim against him was dismissed.

    Close family and four lawyer colleagues acted as character witnesses for Pachai during the hearing. They labelled his actions as being out of character.

    In the meantime, Pachai asked the Law Society of Upper Canada to impose a lengthy ban, but the panel disagreed, noting the mitigating circumstances weren’t sufficient “to justify a second chance.”

    “There is no satisfactory explanation for his misconduct; it was a self-interested, economic choice which was not forced upon him, even if it was devised and initiated by Mr. Sansanwal.

    Nor was it unavoidable, in the sense that it was out of character because it was caused by a disability, addiction or any similar factor,” wrote Bencher Raj Anand on behalf of the three-person panel.

    The panel awarded no costs, noting Pachai had co-operated fully and wouldn’t be able to pay since having voluntarily ceased practice in 2008.
  • Claire Laforest on 2015-06-08 5:18:59 PM
    The proposed reductions in auto insurance coverage are outrageous!! Unless you have walked a day with Sara and the family during the last 19 months, you have no idea what catastrophic injuries stemming from a brain injury caused by the MVA can do to someone emotionally, physically and financially. You may think that the proposed $500,000 for each of nursing care and medical/rehab therapy over a lifetime is a lot of money but it's not! We have so far spent close to $150,000 to $200,000 on Sary Buckley's injuries with nursing care and rehab and were not even at the 2 year anniversary yet. Home health care agencies charge between $25-$55/hr for PSW and RPN care while the current insurance coverage allows for $15/hr for 400 hours/mth or 150 hours/mth at the industry rate. Therapists charge between $100 and $150/hr plus mileage and report writing. Sara requires a physiotherapist 3X/week, a speech therapist once to twice a week, a rehab therapist every day and an occupational therapist every week. You think that's a lot? Well, it's not when someone like Sara requires 24/7 care; she cannot walk, talk, feed, bathe or dress herself nor maintain continence. All this at 18!! And then add to that the expenses related to the drugs and tube feed not covered by extended health private insurance and the cost of accommodating the accessibility to her home. The proposed changes will reduce the current $2M in total allowance by half. And this total $2M is not even what a survivor receives upon settlement because of lawyer fees. These changes must be protested. Proposed changes are going to be devastating. On behalf of all future MVA victims, the proposed changes have to be stopped. Please sign petitions!! Please participate in protests!! Contact your MPPs!! And the Ontario Government should be ashamed of what they are putting forward, in effect Sept. 2015!!
  • Griswald G on 2015-06-08 9:30:24 PM
    The public has no concept of what rehabilitation and recovery can cost. Very few of us could afford what we might need if we were brain-injured or catastrophically impaired. The sense of urgency in Claire's posting is what most people feel when faced with coping with injured loved ones. Our government has failed us on many fronts when it comes to auto insurance and has allowed the IBC to misinform us of the coverage we have with their constant propaganda that everything is fine here, nothing to see, move along, we just need a few more dollars to keep us going and hey look - we can just get it from the victims - especially the worst off ones because they are least likely to be able to complain about it. Maybe there is something to see, and it all played out at the Rally last week when severely injured people showed up to help others they don't even know. And that's a darned sight more than our insurance companies do when we get injured in a crash. What do we get - shipped off to some assessment mill and a denial letter in the mail. Time to consider other possibilities like public auto insurance in Ontario.
  • Brian on 2015-06-08 11:06:52 PM
    Who to believe? That is the question. We can believe the picture being painted by the IBC lobbyists. They would have us believe the insurers money is spent on people who only pretend to be catastrophically injured - and who - even if they are catastrophically injured - are getting to much treatment and too much attendant care. Twice as much in fact. Or, we can listen to the decisions of triers of fact (the judges and arbitrators) who scrutinize the way in which the insurers too often "treat" their most vulnerable claimants. You be the judge. Here (excerpts below) is a case. Who would you trust - the IBC's version of the story or this Arbitrator's decision. The Ontario auto insurance litigation landscape is littered with cases like this one chronicling all manner of insurer abuses. This case manager ought to be ashamed for her implausible (falsified?) reports submitted time and again and used to justify denial of care. Isn't falsifying reports in this way a crime? If not - it ought to be.
    Michalski and Wawanesa [+] Arbitration, 2005-12-13, Reg 403/96.
    Final Decision


    Each of the case manager's subsequent reports to Wawanesa, in March, April, May, June and July, 2002 state in the body of the report that Dr. Dobrowolski continues to report further improvement. I find each of those comments at significant odds with the contents of Dr. Dobrowolski's notes, records, reports to third parties, and an implausible summary of his opinion....

    ...I do not know why Wawanesa preferred the opinions of the occupational therapists and the case manager, flawed and deficient as they were, to the opinions of its own psychiatrist and psychologist, whose greater expertise in assessing Mrs. Michalski's cognitive function Wawanesa sought. I find Wawanesa failed to act with sound and moderate judgment in reassessing evidence from its own assessors. I find Wawanesa's actions and defaults overlap and compound each other.

    ...I believe the sanction should reflect that Wawanesa failed to meet its contractual obligations, and is entirely to blame for the manner in which this claim unfolded. I agree with the submission of counsel for the Applicant that it is difficult to find a more vulnerable Applicant than Mrs. Michalski, who, as a result of her injuries, functions like a two year old, was unrepresented by counsel and whose primary language was not English. She could not be safely left alone. Wawanesa repeatedly put her at risk. Fortunately, her husband and children provided her with care. I believe the award should also reflect that Wawanesa took advantage of Mrs. Michalski's children, and should encompass the need to deter Wawanesa and other insurers from engaging in similar conduct. Nothing indicates that Wawanesa is likely to be subjected to any additional penalty as a result of its misconduct. I agree with the view that interest is remedial C not a penalty.
  • R DeKramer on 2015-06-09 7:09:40 PM
    Here's what a well-known insurer medical assessment doctor told his college when called to task for his poor quality medical report:
    There are three types of patients:
    1.Patients with nothing wrong with them who are “pulling the wool over everyone’s eyes”
    2. Patients with no problem who think they have a problem. These patients actually believe that there is something wrong with them, even though there is not.
    3. Patients with minor problem who have exaggerated this problem into something much bigger than it is.

    Do mva victims even have a chance? Not if there's no room to even consider an injury. A blindness caused by the insurers handpicking and handsomely paying their medical experts so they deny injuries even exist. This is the system and what victims face every day. 

     

Medical-Rehabilitation & Attendant Care - Summary of Cuts to Accident Benefits

Click here to email your MPP today about these cuts!

  • Rehabilitation (“rehab”) benefits cover a range of medically necessary goods and services that aren’t funded in the public system such as physiotherapy, speech therapy, psychology, medications, accessibility renovations, nursing, wheelchairs, artificial limbs, etc.
  • Attendant care (“AC”) benefits cover the services of personal support workers to assist with bathing, dressing, toileting, etc.
  • All goods and services are always subject to the insurer’s determination of what is “reasonable and necessary”, so insurers can deny any request for rehab or AC services even if funds are available
  • There are approximately 65,000 people injured in motor vehicle accidents in Ontario each year: minor injuries account for about 80% of all injuries, serious injuries account for about 19%, and catastrophic injuries account for just 1%; insurers have strong controls over which individuals get classified into which severity category
1996
2010
2014
Budget 2015
Rehab for Minor and Serious Injuries:
$100,000 plus the cost of assessments; minor injuries were subject to care pathways
AC for Serious Injuries:
$72,000
Rehab for Catastrophic Injuries:
$1,000,000 plus the cost of assessments
Attendant Care for Catastrophic Injuries:
$1,000,000
Rehab for Minor Injuries:
$2,200 with an option for an additional $1,300; in-home assessments eliminated
Rehab for Serious Injuries*:
$50,000 including the cost of assessments (approximately a 65% cut in benefits)
AC for Serious Injuries:
$36,000 (a 50% cut)
Rehab for Catastrophic Injuries:
$1,000,000 including the cost of assessments (approximately a 20% cut in benefits)
Attendant Care for Catastrophic Injuries:
$1,000,000
Rehab for Minor Injuries:
No further changes to limits but additional documentation required
Rehab for Serious Injuries*:
No further change to limits
AC for Serious Injuries:
$36,000 for outside caregivers; family member caregivers must demonstrate direct economic loss
Rehab for Catastrophic Injuries:
No further change to limits
Attendant Care for Catastrophic Injuries:
$1,000,000 for outside caregivers; family member caregivers must demonstrate direct economic loss
Rehab for Minor Injuries:
Awaiting a report with recommendations
Rehab and AC for Serious Injuries**:
$65,000 combined (a $21,000 or additional 25% cut)
Rehab and AC for Catastrophic Injuries**:
$1,000,000 combined (a $1,000,000 or additional 50% cut)
Budget also suggests changing the criteria for “catastrophic”
 
* Optional Benefits
In 2010, the government introduced “optional benefits” to allow buyers of auto insurance to buy better coverage.  Our members’ experience with agents and brokers is that this is rarely discussed when policy renewals come up and most brokers are unable to speak to what med-rehab and attendant care benefits cover.  Data from FSCO released a couple years ago confirmed that less than 2% of policy holders bought optional coverage.  This is in stark contrast to optional liability coverage which agents and brokers always encourage policy holders to increase from the mandated $200,000 to $1,000,000 or $2,000,000 (liability coverage pays for the rehabilitation and expenses of someone a policy holder injures in an accident, whereas accident benefits pay for one’s own rehabilitation and expenses when injured).  It is unconscionable that drivers in Ontario are encouraged to ensure they cover someone else’s health care needs to the tune of $2,000,000 in coverage, yet are told that they need less than $50,000 to cover their own health care needs.
 
** Combining Rehab and AC Benefits
The 2015 budget suggests combining rehabilitation and attendant care benefits into one fund, meaning the most seriously of injured people (e.g., those who are paralyzed, people with amputated legs or arms, individuals with severe brain damage, etc.) will be required to choose between getting help to maintain their personal hygiene (bathing, toileting, dressing, etc.) or getting rehabilitation to improve their functional abilities.  This represents one of the most distasteful slashes to the dignity of those with disabilities in the province of Ontario, and because of the small percentage of people who fall into these categories, the savings to insurance companies will be negligible.
 
SUMMARY OF IMPACT ON DISABLED ONTARIANS
Prior to the 2015 Budget announcement, Ontario had already devolved to having the worst rehab insurance coverage in the country on a weighted average basis (80% of injuries access up to $3,500, 19% access up to $50,000 and 1% up to $1,000,000 = weighted average of up to $22,300 in available rehab benefits, if the insurer approves the funding).  With the 2015 Budget announcement, this figure drops to an appalling $15,400.  In 6 years, the Ontario government has reduced rehab funding in the auto sector from a weighted average of $50,000 to $15,000 – and this in the context of publicly funded outpatient and home care rehab services being drastically reduced or eliminated in most jurisdictions across the province.

Numerous other changes have been made to the Accident Benefits package in the past 6 years, all designed to constantly boost insurers’ profitability and all on the backs of injured and vulnerable Ontarians.  The important balance between insurer profitability, premium levels and consumer protection was pushed to the brink in 2010 and will be completely destroyed with the 2015 Budget announcement.  Our government passes seatbelt, helmet and smoking laws to keep people safe.   And one of our most deeply held Canadian values is to provide a safety net for the most vulnerable among us.  The Ontario government needs to show that it cares as much about its citizens as it does about insurer profitability.  Disabled Ontarians and their families are too busy trying to get through basic daily activities with some dignity and hope; they can’t lobby the way the insurance industry can.  You, our MPP, need to be their voice. 

Please stop these proposed changes, review insurer profitability, and let the impact of all the other cuts take place before enacting any new regulations that further disadvantage injured Ontarians.

Source: http://www.ontariorehaballiance.com/page/insurancechanges

Hundreds rally against cuts to auto insurance benefits

By , Toronto Sun
First posted: | Updated:  

TORONTO - Changes to auto insurance benefits for motor vehicle accident victims passed in the Ontario legislature Wednesday as part of the provincial budget.

“God help us all,” Tammy Kirkwood said upon hearing the news. “We’re getting a lot less coverage for a lot more money and I’m not sure why.”

Kirkwood was one of hundreds of protesters at Queen’s Park rallying against reductions in auto insurance benefits which they say will have the most effect on victims with catastrophic injuries.

The 47-year-old Orillia woman said protesters were “flabbergasted” that the provincial government “was trying to disable our resources and our funding to recover.”

Part of the changes to auto insurance rules under the new budget mean that combined coverage for medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits for the catastrophically injured will be cut in half from its current cap of $2 million to $1 million.

Kirkwood survived a 2008 collision when a dump truck hit her car. She had to be pried free from her vehicle by firefighters, and was deemed catastrophically injured.

She says she was only able to move forward because she had access to the services she needed.

Unable to return to work, Kirkwood now volunteers as an advocate with FAIR Association of Victims for Accident Insurance Reform.

New Democratic Party MPP Jagmeet Singh spoke at the rally in support of their cause.

The cuts affect “the most vulnerable people,” such as people with brain and spinal cord injuries, he said.

“They need benefit coverage ... to live an at least somewhat decent life,” Singh pointed out.

A spokesman for Finance Minister Charles Sousa said the government is “working hard to create a fair and affordable insurance system” for the province’s 9.4 million drivers.

Ontario is “the only province in Canada to offer exclusive catastrophic coverage,” Kelsey Ingram said in an e-mail.

“Catastrophically impaired claimants will also continue to be able to sue an at-fault party to recover damages for health-care expenses and potentially other claims,” she added.

The provincial government is also committed to making sure any savings from these changes do not result in “excess profits” for insurance companies, Ingram said.

“This is about lowering premiums while providing support and protection for all Ontario drivers,” she said.

maryam.shah@sunmedia.ca




Friday, May 29, 2015

Advocacy groups to hold rally protesting “very shady” industry practices


by Jill Gregorie | 29 May 2015

In response to last week’s advancement of Bill 91, Building Ontario Up Act, two advocacy groups are organizing a public protest to be held on June 3rd at Queen’s Park, Toronto called #Rally4AccidentVictims.

FAIR Association of Victims for Accident Insurance Reform and the Accident Benefit Coalition are not just protesting provincial government, however.

The groups feel that insurance companies also unfairly benefit from the legislation, and allege that provincial government’s proposals to reduce coverage for the catastrophically injured is uncalled for, given the industry’s profit margins.

“It is unacceptable to be giving away money to wealthy insurance companies who are already using some very shady business practices to deny a record number of claims,” reads a release from FAIR.

Among these practices, FAIR contends, are insurance companies employing "for-hire physicians who provide insurers with the medical reports used to decide whether or not an injured claimant is entitled to treatment and benefits.”

In addition, the non-profit association alleges that this arrangement allows insurance companies to place severely injured victims in numerous social services programs, forcing taxpayers to cover their expenses instead of insurance payouts.

“Our government is giving insurers a financial gift by allowing insurers to pay injured victims less and simultaneously download the cost of victims to the unsuspecting taxpayers who are the same drivers looking for a break on insurance premiums,” FAIR said.

The groups are also calling for supporters to sign an online petition.





Tuesday, May 5, 2015

Ontario Budget: Drivers and Accident Victims set to pay the price for Further Auto Insurance Coverage Restrictions

Trial Lawyers Call for Immediate Pause in "reforms"
 
TORONTO, April 24, 2015 /CNW/ - Ontario Trial Lawyers Association (OTLA) is calling on the Ontario government to hit the pause button on sweeping restrictions to coverage announced in yesterday's provincial budget.
OTLA is recommending a moratorium on any changes pending thorough consultations with all stakeholders in the auto insurance sector on how to fairly and equitably reduce rates and ensure continued fair coverage for victims.

Source/more:

http://www.newswire.ca/en/story/1524445/ontario-budget-drivers-and-accident-victims-set-to-pay-the-price-for-further-auto-insurance-coverage-restrictions

Tuesday, March 31, 2015

Reform done right: In praise of Nova Scotia auto insurance

Nova Scotia boasts one of Canada’s most-effective auto insurance systems. Premiums are among the lowest in the country, with the average policy cost sitting around $780 a year. Compare that to Ontario, where drivers pay about twice that amount.

http://thechronicleherald.ca/opinion/1274500-reform-done-right-in-praise-of-nova-scotia-auto-insurance

Sunday, March 22, 2015

Local voice against wrongful benefit denials still speaking out

March, 12, 2015 - 11:11:26 AM

Local voice against wrongful benefit denials still speaking out
BY SHANNON DUFF EXPRESS MANAGING EDITOR

Editor’s note: The following is the second installment of a story featuring local insurance advocate Jokelee Vanderkop and her efforts to help legitimate claimants ensure they receive their rightful benefits.

Palmerston – After a life-altering motor vehicle collision and more than a decade of battling to receive the insurance benefits she paid for, Palmerston resident Jokelee Vanderkop said she refocused her anger into an energetic effort to expose “what goes on for the majority of motor vehicle accident claimants.”
Those efforts resulted in not only her book — So You Think You’re Covered! The Insurance Industry Rip-off — but also the opportunity to speak on CBC’s Ontario Today radio show in January.

“The host said she had never seen the [call-in] board light up so completely before a show had even started,” Vanderkop said. “The accident victims who spoke of their negative experiences with their insurers were very moving. One woman said she had spent six months in intensive care after an accident and was denied benefits. Another said the insurer’s lawyer told her that he was paid over $500,000 per year to deny her.”

Ten days after the show, Vanderkop received an explanation of benefits from her insurer, stating that since she now had earnings, the company could not consider further payments until it received copies of her earning statements.
Vanderkop said the letter left her shaking her head.

“What earnings?” she asked. “No mention was made of how [I] was supposedly making these earnings.”

In a February interview with finance and consumer journalist Ellen Roseman, Vanderkop stated the insurance company does have a right to request information, but “normally they tell you it’s required in order to continue benefits. In my case, they cut me off first.”

Joe Daly of Desjardins General Insurance Co. said the situation was a misunderstanding and indicated questions arose once the company learned of Vanderkop’s book.

“When we learned that Ms. Vanderkop published and is promoting a book, we sent her a standard form asking for copies of her tax returns,” he explained to Roseman. “Under the legislation, a portion of any income she earns from the book, or any other source, could be deducted from the weekly income replacement benefits we send her. We naturally assume she wrote the book to earn income.”

“If her tax returns indicate she has little or no income from the book or other sources, then her weekly entitlement payments will not be affected.”
Daly continued, “In retrospect, the claims advisor who decided to send the form obviously didn’t understand the realities of publishing in Canada. It’s tough to make any money writing a book.”

Indeed, the book has been more of an expense than anything, said Vanderkop.
Rhona DesRoches, chairperson of FAIR Association of Victims for Accident Insurance Reform [FAIRAssociation.ca], a not-for-profit advocacy group for motor-vehicle accident victims and insurance reform, also appeared on the CBC radio show with Vanderkop.

Vanderkop’s and others’ experiences, said DesRoches, indicates that benefits aren’t a sure thing.

“I think it is outrageous that a person’s benefits are always at risk,” she said in an interview with Roseman. “Settling a case with an insurer is no guarantee that the negative experience of making a claim with auto insurance benefits is really over.”

Vanderkop and DesRoches have since kept in contact, joined in their efforts to help legitimate claimants receive their benefits.

FAIR treatment

FAIR is predominately made up of accident victims, their family members and supporters, DesRoches explained.

“We’re a voice for those victims who really can’t speak out for themselves. Accident victims tend not to speak very loudly,” DesRoches said in an interview with The Minto  Express.

“Jokelee is an unusual person in that she speaks up and speaks out. Predominately accident victims are very quiet about what’s happened to them,” she said.

FAIR members advocate for change and education. “We find a lot of accident victims don’t know what they’re entitled to or why this is happening to them. People are very isolated, and they’re not sure why,” said DesRoches.

The association was founded in 2011, and DesRoches, a member since 2012, said motor accident victims finally have a voice at the table.

“Prior to FAIR, there was always complications,” she said. “But, there really wasn’t anyone at the table to give the accident victims’ perspective on how difficult the system is, and why it isn’t working.”

“Auto insurance isn’t just unaffordable, it’s also problematic in the quality of service it delivers,” DesRoches continued. “We’ve made ourselves a voice. A lot of what we do is directed towards our legislators and various other stakeholders in the auto insurance field. We do consult and submit on various issues that come up.”

Vanderkop, whose book is available at www.deniedbenefitclaims.com and who is available for speaking engagements, says she is now concerned about the recent passing of Bill 15. The Fighting Fraud and Reducing Automobile Insurance Rates Act is being touted as a good thing, she said, but could only make things more difficult for accident victims making claims.

Editor’s note: Please see next week’s Minto Express for the next installment of this story.

Source: http://www.southwesternontario.ca/news/local-voice-against-wrongful-benefit-denials-still-speaking-out/
If you have something to say about the quality of the IMEs in Ontario and the doctors who perform these services, this is a good place to comment. Deadline April 1, 2015.

Current College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario CPSO consultations in respect to transparency at:  http://www.cpso.on.ca/Policies-and-Publications/Consultations  and   http://policyconsult.cpso.on.ca/?page_id=4981   Consultation closes April 1, 2015.
Current comments regarding transparency at:  http://policyconsult.cpso.on.ca/?page_id=5062
Past comments regarding transparency at: http://policyconsult.cpso.on.ca/?page_id=2420

Source: http://www.fairassociation.ca/
 

Friday, February 20, 2015

Writing a book can lead to repercussions: Roseman

Jokelee Vanderkop fought two insurance companies to get benefits after a car accident. Now she’s fighting to keep her benefits after writing a book.

Jokelee Vanderkop wrote a book about how to fight your insurance company to get benefits. Now she’s preparing for another fight about her benefits.
In 2008, she won a lawsuit against the Personal Insurance Co. after a car accident left her unable to continue working as a high school teacher. When the company appealed in 2009, she won again.

She was 44 when injured in 1997. Now 62, she lives on income replacement benefits paid by her insurer. 

Hoping to share her experiences of a court battle that lasted more than a decade, she put out a self-published book, So You Think You’re Covered? The Insurance Industry Ripoff, in 2013.

Most of the 200 copies were given away to friends or dumped, she says. When told the writing was weak, she published a revised edition last fall and sold 84 copies (at $25 apiece).

As part of her publicity campaign, she was a guest on an hour-long CBC radio phone-in program on Jan. 21, Ontario Today. It didn’t take long for her insurance company to follow up.

“I received a letter, dated Jan. 31, saying I now had earnings that could be deducted from my benefits entitlement,” she says. “They said they could not consider any further payments until I submitted my earnings statements and my tax returns for the last five years.

“The insurance company has a right to request information, but normally they tell you it’s required in order to continue benefits. In my case, they cut me off first. This is pure intimidation.”

Desjardins General Insurance Co., which owns The Personal, said there was a misunderstanding about her benefits being cut off.

“When we learned that Ms. Vanderkop published and is promoting a book, we sent her a standard form asking for copies of her tax returns,” explained spokesperson Joe Daly.

“Under the legislation, a portion of any income she earns from the book, or any other source, could be deducted from the weekly income replacement benefits we send her. We naturally assume that she wrote the book to earn income.
“Please note that we have not cut off her benefits and have no intention of doing so. If her tax returns indicate that she has little or no income from the book or other sources, then her weekly entitlement payments will not be affected.
“We didn’t send the note to intimidate Ms. Vanderkop. We were just curious if she was now working as a writer, which is a difficult and demanding job, and earning income.

“In retrospect, the claims adviser who decided to send the form obviously didn’t understand the realities of publishing in Canada. It’s tough to make any money writing a book.”

Rhona Desroches is chair of a non-profit advocacy group called FAIR, the Association of Victims for Accident Insurance Reform. She was a guest on the CBC radio show with Vanderkop.

“We heard from six to eight callers, who all had benefit claims that were about seven years old,” she says. “The people were injured and not in the best shape. I found it very moving.”

Desroches has heard from many frustrated insurance customers. She finds Vanderkop’s story a bit more complicated than most because there were two insurers battling it out at her expense.

She was insured by Personal under a motor vehicle policy and by Manulife under her employer’s group policy. When Manulife denied her application for long-term disability benefits in 1997, she ended up settling for a $57,500 lump sum during a private mediation in 2002.

After the mediation, Personal refused to pay income replacement benefits to Vanderkop, even though she met the test for entitlement, because of the settlement she made with Manulife. Personal argued that it could deduct any long-term disability benefits that might have been payable had Vanderkop been successful in her litigation. 

The Ontario Court of Appeal said income replacement benefits could be reduced by long-term disability benefits resulting from an accident. But Personal could not set off hypothetical benefits applied for, but refused. 

The long legal fight has led to other health problems for Vanderkop. But she’s keen to give tips to accident victims, such as not keeping a journal during a hearing (since it may be confiscated and used as evidence).

Desroches draws a lesson from the author’s tussle with her insurer about potential book earnings.

“I think it is outrageous that a person’s benefits are always at risk,” she says. “Settling a case with an insurer is no guarantee that the negative experience of making a claim with auto insurance benefits is really over.”
Ellen Roseman writes about personal finance and consumer issues. You can reach her at eroseman@thestar.ca or www.ellenroseman.com
 
 
Source :http://www.thestar.com/business/personal_finance/2015/02/10/writing-a-book-can-lead-to-repercussions-roseman.html
 

Fair Association Submission to Pre-budget consultation

Minister,

I am a motor vehicle accident survivor and I suffered with a severe brain injury.  The funding and resources available to me in the Statutory Accident Benefit Schedule (SABS) of 2008 assisted me in my recovery.  I worked for the government in the Ministry of Social Services and Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services, prior to the accident.  I am well aware of the social services programs.

I am appalled that the insurance industries are being allowed to download THEIR responsibilities of injured MVA victims to our already overloaded social services to save their profits.

The resources necessary to recover from a MVA, are readily available to the survivors through the rehabilitation services resources through the insurers.  The same resources and funding is NOT available through our social services.

With the legislation constantly being changed and benefits slashed by your government, you are assisting the insurers to bully, delay and deny the vulnerable persons who entered a contract to assist them when necessary.  Your government made insurance mandatory to operate a vehicle, but your government is deleting the mandatory responsibilities of the insurers and allowing them to breech the contracts we, the people, are made to sign.

The endless and expensive IME (independent medical examination) being used by the insurers to delay and deny victims is traumatizing some of the most vulnerable population.

The monies being taken out of the medical and rehabilitative benefits, is not being used to assist a victim to return to state of well being. It’s being used to abuse the victims and ultimately line the pockets of others to make money on the backs of a vulnerable population.

I truly believe OUR tax dollars and our government’s supports should be used to assist all Ontarians and NOT support wealthy insurance companies to escape their responsibilities to auto accident survivors!


Tammy Kirkwood
Vice Chair
www.fairassociation.ca



Source: http://www.fairassociation.ca/



Sunday, February 1, 2015

NDP wants secret info on Ontario’s top billing doctors made public


January 22, 2015 3:29 pm

AP Photo/Cleveland Clinic, Janine Sot

Personal injury lawyer launches challenge against Bill 15

by |

A lawyer has launched a constitutional challenge on behalf of automobile accident victims aimed directly at Bill 15.

Lawyer and advocate Joseph Campisi is launching a constitutional challenge in the Ontario Superior Courts, seeking a declaration that parts of the legislation that were recently passed by the Liberal Government are discriminatory and unconstitutional and should be inoperative.

“The right to access the Superior Courts is a fundamental right for Canadians.  I am concerned that the recent proclaimed legislation will deny this right to individuals who have been severely disabled,” said personal injury lawyer Joseph Campisi.  “Historically, the deck has been stacked against automobile victims. The recent amendments to the legislation have turned a bad situation into a worse one for these vulnerable individuals.”

In the fall, of 2014, the Ontario passed Bill 15, which took aim at fraud in the insurance industry with the aim of reducing insurance rates.

One of the legislative amendments changes how disputes between insurers and insured are settled, which has raised the ire of groups like FAIR and those in the health care industry, like the Ontario Rehab Alliance.

Historically, disputes could be brought before the Superior Courts or before arbitrators with expertise in interpreting insurance law.  Bill 15 has changed how disputes are resolved by giving the sole adjudicative power to individuals who will be appointed “at the whim of the Liberal Government,” said Campisi.

“No longer will these individuals be allowed to have the assurance of impartiality and independence that is a cornerstone of our justice system when litigating a claim against their own insurance company,” said Campisi. “I could not stand idly by and let this happen.”

These are the same decision makers who jurisdiction on matters ranging from film classification to upholstered and stuffed articles, Campisi went on to say, adding that unlike historical appointments individuals without any specialization or guaranteed independence or impartiality will be ruling on disputes that can run into the millions of dollars and will determine the quality of life that an automobile victim will face going forward.

“This application will challenge Bill 15 on the basis that it violates disabled person’s Charter s.15 (1) right to be free from discrimination,” he said. “Bill 15 is also being challenged based on s.96 of the Constitution which relates to the public’s right to have access to the courts.  The way in which Bill 15 is drafted opens the door to political interference.  The government of the day can choose who will hear any dispute and if the government does not agree with the arbitrator’s decisions, the government can get rid of the adjudicator the next day.  When it comes to lobbying the government there is little doubt as to who has the deeper pockets; automobile insurers or accident victims.  Introducing such laws is undemocratic and detracts from the rule of law.  This legal challenge will fight for disabled individuals’ right to fair treatment and the public’s right to access the impartial court system.”

Barb Taylor, the director of policy at the Insurance Bureau of Canada, had spoken out last Thursday on what she saw as “strong opponents” of those fighting for change in the insurance industry. Click here for the article, 15 per cent target for Ontario auto 'does not compute'

“We have strong opponents. These groups also have the ear of government and will seek media attention. Specifically, I am talking about trial lawyers, medical rehab providers and the NDP,” Taylor told those gathered for the 2015 Crystal Ball conference. “We are asking the (Ontario) government to require personal injury lawyers and paralegals who represent auto insurance claimants to submit to the Superintendent all information about their fees – including contingency fee arrangements, disbursements, court awarded and settled costs, and referral arrangements."

Source: http://www.insurancebusiness.ca/news/personal-injury-lawyer-launches-challenge-against-bill-15-187471.aspx?p=2

Monday, January 26, 2015

Resolving auto insurance benefit disputes stacked against public

By , Toronto Sun
First posted: | Updated: Auto insurance claims 
TORONTO - With last year’s passage of Bill 15, the “Fighting Fraud and Reducing Automobile Insurance Rates Act, 2014”, the handling of accident benefits disputes in Ontario is to be passed from the Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO) to the Licence Appeal Tribunal (LAT).
There are obvious reasons for the public to fear this transition.

FSCO handles about 10,000 applications each year, compared to LAT’s 700.
FSCO arbitrators and mediators have a wealth of experience in a highly specialized area, while LAT members have no experience in accident benefits disputes.

Instead, LAT members have expertise in liquor licence appeals, reviews of medical suspension of drivers’ licences, motor vehicle impoundments and claims under the Ontario New Home Warranties Plan.

Courtesy of Canadians for Properly Built Homes (CFPBH), a national, non-profit consumer protection organization, we have a report analyzing 2006-2013 LAT decisions pertaining to homeowner appeals of Tarion decisions concerning new home warranties.

Tarion is the private corporation created by the Ontario government to protect new homebuyers and administer new home warranties, although its board of directors is controlled by builders.

CFPBH has concluded LAT’s “operations and performance need improvement both in relation to the adjudicators themselves (specifically in relation to self-represented parties) and the LAT’s management and administrative processes.”

The numbers in the CFPBH study present a dire picture for homeowners who dare to enter the LAT’s chambers.

During the eight-year period of the study, LAT gave homeowners a 96% failure rate in relation to major deficiency claims.

The annual failure rate for total issues presented by homeowners in the last three years of the study is 82%, 83% and 94%.

The number of appeals brought before LAT dropped from 119 in the first four years of the study to 69 in the last four.

It’s impossible to know why the numbers have dropped off but CFPBH believes many homeowners have given up and made repairs themselves while some have resorted to what they call “patch and run” tactics.

That is, homeowners patch up the deficiencies and place their homes on the market for resale without disclosing the builders’ defects.

Still others bypass LAT completely and pursue remedies through the courts.
Yet this very avenue has been taken away from those seeking accident benefits arising from vehicle crashes.

Bill 15 removes this option and forces all accident benefit claims to be resolved without recourse to courts.

Karen Somerville, President of CFPBH, believes LAT has “serious shortcomings” and purchasers of new homes urgently need — and deserve — a fair and appropriate appeal process for the largest purchase most consumers make: a home.

LAT’s numbers seem to support Somerville’s contention. Certainly there doesn’t appear to be a level playing field between homeowners and Tarion.
All of which begs the question, why was LAT chosen to administer the automobile insurance dispute resolution system?

Hopefully many current FSCO arbitrators will be moved over to LAT so their expertise won’t be lost.

But that doesn’t change the fact LAT members are part-time (other than the Associate Chair), appointed for temporary terms, receive per diem rates (other than the Associate Chair), and are government appointees.

Reappointment is at the pleasure of the Ontario cabinet, so they cannot be seen as independent.

Current FSCO arbitrators are full-time, unionized, public sector employees.
It is difficult to see how the transfer of jurisdiction from FSCO to LAT will serve to either fight auto insurance fraud or reduce rates, although it is easy to see how the transfer will result in massive new expenditures and may result in injustices.

But shouldn’t we first be fixing LAT and providing purchasers of new homes with meaningful remedies, before we throw 10,000 new auto insurance disputes at it?


Saturday, January 24, 2015

Constitutional Challenge Launched Against Flawed Ontario Liberal Government Auto Insurance Legislation- Discriminatory and Unconstitutional

January 21, 2015
 
Toronto, January 21, 2015 – Joseph Campisi, lawyer and advocate, is launching a constitutional challenge in the Ontario Superior Courts.  Mr. Campisi is seeking a declaration from the courts that parts of the legislation that were recently passed by the Liberal Government are discriminatory and unconstitutional and should be inoperative.

“The right to access the Superior Courts is a fundamental right for Canadians.  I am concerned that the recently proclaimed legislation will deny this right to individuals who have been severely disabled.” said applicant and noted Personal Injury Lawyer Joseph Campisi.  “Historically, the deck has been stacked against collision victims.  The recent amendments to the legislation have turned a bad situation into a worse one for these vulnerable individuals.  No longer will these individuals be allowed to have the assurance of impartiality and independence that is a cornerstone of our justice system when litigating a claim against their own insurance company.  I could not stand idly by and let this happen.”

In the fall, of 2014, the Ontario Government passed Bill 15 which is titled Fighting Fraud and Reducing Automobile Insurance Rates.  One of the legislative amendments changes how disputes between insurers and insured are settled.  Historically, disputes could be brought before the Superior Courts or before sophisticated arbitrators with expertise in interpreting insurance law.  Bill 15 has changed how disputes are resolved by giving the sole adjudicative power to individuals who will be appointed at the whim of the Liberal Government.  These are the same decision makers who have jurisdiction on matters ranging from film classification to upholstered and stuffed articles. Unlike historical appointments, individuals without any specialization or guaranteed independence or impartiality will be ruling on disputes that can run into the millions of dollars and will determine the quality of life that an automobile victim will face going forward.

“This application will challenge Bill 15 on the basis that it violates disabled persons’ Charter s.15 (1) right to be free from discrimination.  Bill 15 is also being challenged based on s.96 of the Constitution which relates to the public’s right to have access to the courts.  The way in which Bill 15 is drafted opens the door to political interference.  The government of the day can choose who will hear any dispute and if the government does not agree with the arbitrator’s decisions, the government can get rid of the adjudicator the next day.  When it comes to lobbying the government there is little doubt as to who has the deeper pockets- automobile insurers or accident victims.  Introducing such laws is undemocratic and detracts from the rule of law.  This legal challenge will fight for disabled individuals’ right to fair treatment and the public’s right to access the impartial court system.”

For more information go to https://www.campisilaw.ca
Source Campisi LLP
For further information contact:
Cesar Carranza  cesar@campisilaw.ca

Source: https://www.campisilaw.ca/constitutional-challenge-launched-against-flawed-ontario-liberal-government-auto-insurance-legislation/

Tuesday, January 13, 2015

Misplaced exuberance over Ontario's Bill 15

December 20, 2014

Bill 15, the Fighting Fraud and Reducing Automobile Insurance Rates Act, has now been passed and many people sing its praises because they've been told its good but don't really understand why, other than it fights fraud and will save the insurance industry a lot of money, The true implications of this bill on accident victims is anything but good.

People like Bob Verwey  President of the Trillium Automobile Dealers Association (TADA) is exuberant in his praise for this new legislation. This bill is quite comprehensive and only in small part - the part Mr. Verwey talks about -i.e. reforms to the towing industry - actually helps fight insurance fraud. He is correct that the towing industry needed to be regulated and he may be right when he says that "many consumers have been taken advantage of by unscrupulous tow truck drivers and owners. Some tow truck drivers have coerced motorists into signing waivers or consent forms at the accident scene, allowing vehicles to be towed to a repair facility where the tow operator has a vested interest.

In some cases, tow operators will sell a collision repair job to the highest bidder, earning large commissions or kickbacks. All too often, consumers wind up paying expensive towing and storage fees because they didn't understand their options".  I find it odd though when he points out that: "There are roughly 1,200 tow truck operators and 3,000 tow truck drivers in Ontario, ..... and most of them operate with honesty and integrity. But a few bad apples have given the industry a bad name". This begs the question as to why we needed the Ontario government to step in and bring about legislation for just a "few bad apples". We will find a "few bad apples" in every industry, and also among individual claimants. However, Mr. Verwey doesn't see the forest for the trees in his exuberant praise of the Ontario government for throwing its might behind a "few bad apples". He talks about Bill 15 as if it only addressed the tow truck operators and owners and doesn't appear cognizant of what is behind the rest of the bill which is far from praiseworthy. He seemingly has little understanding about how much of the bill will not fight fraud but will rather serve as a gift of hundreds of thousands of dollars to the insurance industry and this at the expense of motor vehicle accident victims who have been seriously injured. And the reason for this is that one of the aspects of the bill reduces the interest rate that insurers had to pay on settlement amounts when they were less than expedient in paying their clients owed income replacement benefits. The rate for income replacement used to be 2% compounded monthly with interest rates for dragged out tort settlements set at 5% annually not compounded. This was to force insurers to expedite legitimate settlements. The government felt this rate was necessary so that insurers would pay what they owed more quickly as there was a tendency for insurers to use funds that were owed claimants as part of their "float" for investment purposes. Insurers knew they could earn much more to bolster their bottom line even with these high interest rates so it was not uncommon for legitimate claimants who didn't give up their fight to receive benefits to only have their cases settled in the eight to ten year range. Meanwhile, claimants received nothing and had to live off their savings or go broke.  The interest rate is now set at the market rate which at present represents penalty payments at a lowly not compounded annual rate of 1.3%. This rate reduction is the gift. Bill 15 has made it even more financially expedient for insurers to delay payment to legitimate claimants. But the legislation doesn't address insurance denials of legitimate claimants, the years of delays with claimants having to hire a lawyer if they want to stand a chance of getting their benefits, the frequent ineptitude of the IME (insurance medical examination) process which uses for hire medical experts to write reports that more often then not favour the insurer, if not in some instances outright change to a diagnosis written by a claimants medical doctor to downplay the injury (see my Dec 9/14 blog). And then, let us not forget the massively reduced benefits since September 2010 and the introduction of the MIG (minor injury guideline) category which ties most seriously injured claimants to $3,500 for rehabilitation, with the insurer being able to take up to $2,200 of that to cover their assessments. Heck,  the 15% premium reduction could easily have been made just on what insurers saved in 2010.

 Bill 15 also revamps the dispute resolution system for accident benefits to the detriment of accident victims by eliminating the right to sue insurance companies for the denial of benefits. Insurers rarely pay benefits unless the claimant hires a lawyer. The question I ask is why one even needs to hire a lawyer when you pay for insurance coverage for benefits you will need when seriously injured in a car accident? Your case is medically valid and all your medical ducks are in a row. Yet, not only will you usually not get those benefits on the merit of your medical condition but you will have to hire a lawyer, and probably have to go to court to get what you paid for. Well, if you can no longer sue which is what most of us had to do to get paid, and can only go through yet another insurance mediation process which will rarely rule in your favour, how is it that Bill 15 is being touted as the next best thing to sliced bread for insurance claimants. It is, however, the next best thing to sliced bread for the insurance industry.

Steven Polak, a personal injury lawyer with Lerners LLP says that if this legislation goes through (which it now has) "It would be a victory for multi-national behemoth insurers, at the expense of the most vulnerable injured members of our Province. The publicity of cases when the learned Judges of our Courts have slapped insurers with punitive and bad faith awards for wrongful conduct are one of the only means of defence that we have to keep insurers in check. We should not give that away. We should protect it at all costs". He goes on to say, "I have had more than a few cases where insurers have denied benefits (including a recent car accident injury lawsuit in Oshawa/Whitby) for what I considered to be completely outrageous reasons, and we started a lawsuit claiming for punitives, which then met with a reversal of the position by the insurer. Relegating these disputes to some back-room licensing tribunal that just deals with one benefit is far different than the spot-light that a lawsuit with a punitive damages award shines on an insurer. We should not leave ourselves defenseless".

The biggest insurance coup is having people believe that fraud against insurers is the name of the game so any one who is denied must be scamming because otherwise they would be paid. Go to FAIRAssociation.ca a not-for profit association that represents motor vehicle accident victims and ask Chair, Rhona Desroches how often legitimate claimants dealing with a serious injury and/or brain impairments are denied, intimidated, harassed and belittled with many going broke while fighting their insurer with all the emotional implications of having to fight their insurer and deal with a dramatically-changed lifestyle. Google Alan Shanoff of the SUN or Ellen Roseman of the Toronto Star and inform yourself about the other side of the equation - the side that most of us can't even phantom or read "So You Think You're Covered! The Insurance Industry Rip-Off". Can it be that insurers also deal in fraudulent behavior!? - and let's not even talk about extended health carriers or WSIB. Keep your fingers crossed that you are never in a serious accident that requires rehabilitation and income replacement benefits because you can't consistently work at anything that will pay you a living wage. This is when your insurer and all the premiums you have paid will fail you.

Our legislators have rubber stamped a bill of which they know little and are patting themselves on the back for a job well done. They certainly didn't give much time (15 minutes) for the likes of FAIR to present their case on why Bill 15 isn't a good bill. That lack of input didn't apply to the car insurance industry, IBC and all its insurance cohorts.

Source: http://www.deniedbenefitclaims.com/blog.html

Monday, January 12, 2015

Accident or illness benefits denied? Radio show addresses the issues

CBC's Ontario Today, an hour long news and call-in radio show is addressing on Jan 6th the issue of what car insurers and extended health insurers put legitimate claimants through in order to deny their benefits. You can find it at 99.1 or 100.9 or 93.5 (check online for your area) or you can listen online. The call-in number is 1-888 817 8995. The focus of the show is on seriously injured people with medically valid claims who are still being denied.

You would think that benefits would not be denied to people with serious injuries or illnesses but their denial gets ratcheted up big time when the car insurer or extended health carrier know that the illness or injury is serious enough to warrant long-term benefits. Insurers spend more not to pay than to pay legitimate claimants and they use all kinds of unsavory techniques to get you to drop your claim. How they go about this, and how you can protect yourself is all written out in "So You Think You're Covered! The Insurance Industry Rip-Off". Chair, Rhona Desroches who represents FAIR, an organization whose members are mva victims who have been put through hell by their insurers and are thus fighting for insurance reform, has said that the title of my book is very accurate.


If you miss the live radio program you can hear it as a podcast on 'Previous Episodes' at www.cbc.ca/ontariotoday/

 

Source: http://www.deniedbenefitclaims.com/blog.html

 

Sunday, January 4, 2015

FAIR Board Chair, Rhona DesRoches will be on an open line talk show about delays in insurance

Ontario Today, TUE JAN 6th, between 12 and 1pm. FAIR Board Chair, Rhona DesRoches will be on an open line talk show about delays in insurance payouts and the lack of access to benefits. Jokelee Vanderkop will be interviewed about her new book 'So You Think You're Covered! The Insurance Industry Rip-Off', a captivating and all-too-real story about her 12 year long battle for benefits and her odyssey through Ontario's dysfunctional auto insurance system after a car crash in 1997. As much as this book is a personal story it is also a valuable source of information for victims.
 

Ontario Today
The show that invites Ontario listeners to join an on-air conversation about the news of the day. Call 1-888-817-8995.


Jokelee Vanderkops new book 'So You Think You're Covered! The Insurance Industry Rip-Off can be found at:
 http://deniedbenefitclaims.ca/

UPDATE
Tomorrow's CBC Ontario Today show at 12pm has been rescheduled to take place on Wednesday, January 21 at 12pm.
 
 

CPSO Transparency Project – Phase 2 Have your say

Join the discussion

View the feedback and join the conversation on our online discussion page
Deadline for comments:
April 1, 2015

Our Process

View our active consultations
Consultation Process and Posting Guidelines here

A proposal to add information to the public register: Cautions-in-person, Specified Continuing Education and Remediation Plans (SCERPs), criminal charges, medical licences in other jurisdictions, and discipline findings in other jurisdictions


What do patients need to know about physicians to make informed health-care decisions? The College is currently looking to expand the information available about physicians on our public register, and we’re asking for your feedback. Some of this information is related to the work of our Inquiries, Complaints and Reports Committee (ICRC), and some is information that is generated through other processes (criminal charges for example) or regulatory authorities (findings in other jurisdictions).

The Phase 1 consultation closed in December 2014. Council considered your feedback and passed by-laws that allow criminal findings and Health Insurance Act offences, and bail conditions that affect physician practice to be posted on the public register.

We are now asking for your comments on Phase 2 of the transparency consultation. Specifically, the College is proposing amendments to Section 49(1) of the General By-Law, which sets out what information about physicians is included on the public register. In particular, we are proposing that the following information about physicians be included on the public register:
We continue to work with other health regulators as a member of The Advisory Group for Regulatory Excellence (AGRE), in considering making additional information publically available about the health-care professionals we regulate. Committed to a principled and consistent approach, AGRE has developed transparency principles to guide the decision-making process in the Transparency Initiative. These principles continue to inform all recommendations presented to College Councils.

Have Your Say!

  • Submit your comments to our discussion forum
  • Send us your comments by email
  • Send us your comments via regular mail
Source: http://policyconsult.cpso.on.ca/?page_id=4981